If you still have T12s in your building and they run on magnetic ballasts, you may soon face a conundrum: what do you do when your ballasts die?
Well, like T12s themselves, magnetic ballasts are becoming harder and harder to find these days. They're really no longer in production in the U.S., so most people today are running T12 fluorescents on electronic ballasts. What is a ballast? Read more >
Before we get into your options for troubleshooting this dilemma, let's briefly determine how to tell if your ballast is bad.
5 symptoms of a bad fluorescent ballast
If your fluorescent lighting is displaying any of the signs below, it could be a symptom of a bad ballast:
If your lighting is flickering or strobing periodically, it's not necessarily that the bulb, or tube, is about to burn out. It could just as well be that the ballast is going bad.
Bad ballasts often buzz, or hum, when they're on their way out. If you've been hearing this, you need to test the ballast.
If your fluorescent lighting starts to act like HID when you turn it on, and it's slow to reach full illuminance, your ballast is most likely the culprit.
Low lumen output is almost always the cause of one of two things: an old fluorescent lamp or an aging, bad ballast.
Inconsistent lighting levels
Fluorescent lamps almost always experience color variation and fading. So, at different stages of the lamp's life, different light levels will be produced. But if you're seeing dark corners and inconsistent lighting in your space, it may not just be because of the lamps. It could very well be the ballast, too.
Options for replacing your T12 magnetic ballasts
You're going to have a really hard time replacing your magnetic ballast with a new magnetic ballast. But you've probably figured that out by now.
Here's what you can do:
1. Switch to an electronic ballast, keep lamp
This is probably the cheapest, least labor-intensive option, but not by much. Once you understand the total cost of lighting, though, you'll see that there's a better long-term solution. The "work smarter, not harder" approach to this debacle would be to swap out the lamp while you're swapping out the ballast, for a clean, full upgrade.
That said, you can run most T12s off an electronic ballast, so if you think your lamps still have a lot of life in them, this is an option.
Note: If you find that your T12 burned out and your magnetic ballast still has some life, Philips now makes a magnetic-ballast-compatible T8 LED that you may want to check out. Read more here.
2. Switch to an electronic ballast, switch to a T8 fluorescent
As mentioned above, if you're going to climb a ladder to do a ballast change out, you may as well carry a lamp up there with you. Since T12s have been mostly phased out of production, the most affordable option would be to stay with fluorescents, installing a smaller-diameter, more energy-efficient T8 lamp.
3. Switch to an electronic ballast, switch to T8 linear LED
Depending on your application, and the average burn time of your lamps, this is probably the best play for both long-term savings and upfront cost. The cost of linear LEDs has come way down and, all in all, there are very few applications where you'd be better off with fluorescents.
4. Switch from T12 to a new integrated LED fixture or retrofit kit
If you have the capital to completely retrofit your lighting, one option to consider is going with a new LED fixture. This option provides great visual appeal while carrying some of the longest life ratings and highest efficiency options available in a lighting system. Here's a list of pros and cons for this option, from our article, 'LED lamp replacement vs. LED fixture: Which is best for you?':
LED fixture pros
- Maximum control over light output and placement (great for situations where lighting design is paramount)
- Longer life rating and efficacy than LED replacement lamps
- Lower maximum fixture wattage than traditional fixtures, which is advantageous for meeting strict building codes or Title 24 standards
- Excellent performance for controls and dimming
LED fixture cons
- Longer, more expensive installation
- Higher up-front cost than LED replacement lamps
- Potential for difficulty in upgrading to future emerging technologies